Life

The 25 Best Totally Non-Basic Candy Options For Halloween

Beyond candy corn

by Liz Riccardi

First of all, let it be known that I love all candy equally. I can easily eat an entire bag of those mini Butterfinger bars in one setting. And that is a problem.

But it wasn't always so.

My Halloween candy history goes something like this: I grew up in a very unpopulated rural area, on a hill with a quarter-mile-long driveway. Trick-or-treating was always a fun idea in theory, but, in reality, it meant having your parents drive you up and down dark dirt roads, usually in the freezing cold, in hopes of collecting a few granola bars and candy corn. Was it worth it? Not really. When I was around 12 years old, a "haunted" hayride was organized in my hollow as a festive way to shuttle children from house to house. I was the wrong age to appreciate any of the magic or efforts that went into it, and on its very first run, I got my very first period, epically staining my costume and embarrassing me so thoroughly I have no intention of ever "stepping foot" on a hay wagon again. It wasn't until my early 20s that I finally overcame the Halloween disappointments and traumas of my past and began to embrace the season once again. As a nanny in Brooklyn, New York, I became the recipient of all excess candy. Selflessly agreeing to take as many Reese's peanut butter cups as necessary, saving the children (really, the parents) from tummy aches and tantrums, I began to experience Halloween candy as a source of joy.

Unfortunately, as I left my early 20s behind, I began to find that binge-eating candy had much the same effect on me as it had on the seven-year-olds I had once pilfered from.

And so, it has happened: I have slowly come to appreciate quality over quantity when it comes to candy. (I've lived above a Duane Reade for the past six years so you can imagine the physical pain I've been through to reach this point. I mean, see above reference to Butterfinger bars.) The truth is, a nibble from a really good candy bar is way more satisfying than stuffing your face with an entire not-so-good candy bar. And why eat basic candy when there are so many other options?

Click through the gallery below to check out some of my favorite best-looking and best-tasting candy options for the sophisticated palate.

Dottie’s Toffee, Dark Chocolate Tin, $25, available at Dotties Toffee

Cranberry Sweets, Sugar Free Peanut Brittle, $11.95, available at CranberrySweets.com

Dean and Deluca, Pure Chocolate Skull, $18.75, available at Dean and Deluca

L’Abeille Occitane, Honery Pearls Candy with Violet, $8.50, available at TheFrenchFarm.com

Justin’s, Peanut Butter Cups, $2.49 - $136.28, available at Justins.com

Bloomsberry Think Chocolate, 1000mg of Happy Bar, $4.99, available at Bloomsberry Think Chocolate

Big Picture Farm, Farmstead Cider Honey Caramels, $7.49, available at BigPictureFarm.com

Bisous Ciah, Jack-O’-Lantern Macarons, $59, available at Dean and Deluca

Tea Room, Milk Chocolate Bar Infused with Bedouin’s Mint Tea, Organic, $3.29, 5/$15.00, available at Tea Room

Chowards, Violet Mints, $1.09, available at OldTimeCandy.com

Butter & Scotch, Boozy Popcorn Variety Pack , $24, available at Scoutmob.com

Amarelli, Anise Licorice Tin, $4.32, available at Eataly

Recchiiuti Confections, Pates de Fruits, $23, available at Recchiuti.com

Malaco, Allsorts Liquorice Mix Candy 300g, $12.74, available at Amazon.com

Domori, White Chocolate and Matcha Bar, $6, available at CocoaStore.nyc

Dandelion Chocolate, Kokoa Kamili, Tanzania - 70%, $8, available at Dandelion Chocolate

Boissier, Parisian Caramels Candies Pencil Box, $19.99, available at Lepanierfrancais.com

San Churro Chocolateria, Crispy Bliss Balls - Strawberry, two for $12, available at San Churro

Sugar Knife, "Blood And Sand” Jameson Whiskey, Blood Orange Bitters, Tart Dried Cherry Lollipops, $22, available at Sugar Knife

Quin Is Candy, Oregon Cherry Sparkling Candy, $8.50, available at Quin Candy

Wondermade, Fall Flavors Marshmallos, $30 for 4 boxes, available at Wondermade

Black Pig Meat Co., Bacon Toffee Pig Pop, $5.75, available at Mouth.com

Quin Is Candy, Butterscotch Old Fashioned Hard Candies, $5, available at Quin Candy

Canels, Chicle Miniatura 320-piece pack, $4.89, available at mymexicancandy.com

Sugarfina, Pale Ale Pint Gummies, $7.50, available at Sugarfina

Style + Culture, delivered straight to your inbox.
Sign up for our newsletter for the biggest stories in fashion, entertainment, and music. We don't just follow the trends, we set them.
By subscribing to this BDG newsletter, you agree to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy